Paul Kincaid reviews Best Short Novels: 2006 for SF Site. It’s an interesting review and Kincaid is an intelligent critic. The only comment I’d make on it is to clarify that the book is called Best Short Novels omitting reference to genre because it is published by The SF Book Club. Were it published by a trade publisher, it probably would go with the original title from the proposal: The Best Science Fiction and Fantasy Novellas of the Year (which is a mouthful, I know).